MICHIGAN DOMESTIC VIOLENCE - Attorney Jonathan Paul -
  • The New Rules of Domestic Violence
  • Divorce/Family Issues
    • Filing for Divorce
    • Child Custody
    • Parenting Time
    • Moving with the Kids
    • Spousal Support
    • Personal Protection Orders
    • Property Division
    • Retirement Benefits
    • Child Support
    • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Survival Guide
    • Wayne County >
      • Wayne County
      • Plymouth Canton Northville
      • Dearborn
      • Livonia
      • Woodhaven/Brownstown Twp
      • Westland
      • DV Attorney | Arrest Romulus - Belleville - Van Buren Twp
    • Oakland County >
      • Novi
      • Rochester Hills
      • Farmington Hills
      • Royal Oak
      • Troy/Clawson
      • Bloomfield Hills
      • Southfield
      • Waterford
      • Oak Park
      • DV Attorney | Arrest Clarkston/White Lake Domestic Violence
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Pittsfield Township
      • Ypsilanti 14A-2
      • Chelsea
      • Saline
      • Ypsilanti 14-B
    • Ingham County
    • Genesee County
    • Monroe County
    • Jackson County
    • Livingston County
    • DV Attorney | Arrest Macomb County
  • Our Team
  • Meet Jonathan
  • Reviews

Dearborn Domestic Violence Attorney 19th District Court

12/22/2020

 
If after sorting over the pretrial options, a client decides they want to go to trial, we discuss possible defenses.  The problem with most domestic violence cases in Michigan is that my client is probably technically guilty of having "unwanted contact with the victim".  

Most clients believe that domestic violence involves punching, kicking and most commonly "hurting someone" - known of these common believes are required to be charged and found guilty of domestic violence in Michigan.  I typically demonstrate what domestic violence is on my own clients - simply giving them a shove in the shoulder or pushing them out of the way is "unwanted contact" 

The bar is quite low and if my client was present and we don't have a mistaken identity (not happening when there is a domestic relationship) it seems like it would be impossible to win a domestic violence trial.  

The most common ways to win a DV trial are the following:

1. The victim does not want to testify (prosecutor then dismisses) or they don't want to testify (prosecutor doesn't dismiss) but the jury or judge have a difficult time convicting when the victim is denying anything happened.  

2. Self-defense or reasonable response

Going to focus more on the reasonable response; the Michigan Jury Instructions for domestic violence, specifically M Crim JI 17.24a states 

(1) The defendant has raised the defense that [his / her] conduct was a reasonable response to an act of domestic violence. The defendant has the burden of proving this defense. To satisfy this burden, the evidence must persuade you that it is more likely than not that [his / her] conduct was a reasonable response to an act of domestic violence, given all of the facts and circumstances known to[him / her] at the time.

(4) If the defendant has proved that [his / her] conduct was a reasonable response to an act of domestic violence in light of the facts and circumstances known to [him / her] at the time, you must find [him / her]not guilty of _________. If [he / she] has failed to prove this defense, [his / her] defense that [his / her] conduct was a reasonable response to an act of domestic violence fails.

What all this legal language means is if someone is charged with domestic violence, a judge or jury gets to hear what they did from all witnesses and decide if that was reasonable.  That reasonableness is not defined, but up to the jury or judge to decide.  Here are two clear examples, which aren't always the case - it's usually more grey area.

Scenario #1 

1. Defendant claims the victim yelled at him about not paying the bills, and at one point pushed him and told him he was a no good husband.  Victim admits to doing this on the stand, but then says the defendant punched her in the face multiple times and kicked her on the ground.  Defendant claims he was pushed and victim was trying to push him a second time so he reacted.  

Scenario #2

1. Victim and defendant both admit to a verbal fight over bills not being paid.  Victim claims she was shoved by the defendant and pushed out of the way, and she was afraid of the defendant.  Defendant admits he shoved the victim, but claims the victim was cornering him and removed himself out the situation by pushing victim out of the way.  

In scenario #1 it is probably not reasonable to punch and kick someone as a response to pushing and yelling.  In scenario #2, if there is a lot of mutual contact and the defendant simply wants to get away, admitting to pushing someone out of the way may technically be "unwanted touching" but is COULD BE reasonable within that moment.

In Michigan, scenario #2 may offer the defendant a good defense to the domestic violence charges.  The caveat being trial is always risky and alternative options  should always be discussed prior to rolling the dice on your future. ​

Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Call Me: 248-924-9458
    Click to Email Me
    Picture
    10.0Jonathan Andrew Paul

    Categories

    All
    769.4a
    Aggravated DV
    Alcohol/drug Testing
    Am I A Bad Person?
    Asset Allocation
    Being Proactive
    Career/Job Concerns
    Change Of Domicile
    Child Custody
    Child Protective Services
    Child Support
    Confession To Police
    Dismissal
    Divorce
    DV Probation
    DV Trial
    Employment
    Female - DV Charges
    Going To Jail?
    Going To Trial?
    Injury Required?
    Jury Vs Bench Trial
    Kids Testifying
    Material Witness Warrant
    Moving With Kids
    Mutual Incident
    No Contact Order
    No-Contact Order
    Parenting Time
    Penalties For DV
    Prior DV
    Pushing/Shoving
    Retirement
    Returning To The Home
    Seeing Your Kids
    Spousal Privilege
    Spousal Support
    Subpoena
    Taking The House Away
    Travel Requests
    Victim Testifying

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • The New Rules of Domestic Violence
  • Divorce/Family Issues
    • Filing for Divorce
    • Child Custody
    • Parenting Time
    • Moving with the Kids
    • Spousal Support
    • Personal Protection Orders
    • Property Division
    • Retirement Benefits
    • Child Support
    • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Survival Guide
    • Wayne County >
      • Wayne County
      • Plymouth Canton Northville
      • Dearborn
      • Livonia
      • Woodhaven/Brownstown Twp
      • Westland
      • DV Attorney | Arrest Romulus - Belleville - Van Buren Twp
    • Oakland County >
      • Novi
      • Rochester Hills
      • Farmington Hills
      • Royal Oak
      • Troy/Clawson
      • Bloomfield Hills
      • Southfield
      • Waterford
      • Oak Park
      • DV Attorney | Arrest Clarkston/White Lake Domestic Violence
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Pittsfield Township
      • Ypsilanti 14A-2
      • Chelsea
      • Saline
      • Ypsilanti 14-B
    • Ingham County
    • Genesee County
    • Monroe County
    • Jackson County
    • Livingston County
    • DV Attorney | Arrest Macomb County
  • Our Team
  • Meet Jonathan
  • Reviews